Our Open Digital Repository (ODR) offers access to a large collection of selected digital resources supporting ethics and purity of digital content in creative activities, promoting active citizenship, the fight against fake news and digital diversity. Here you will find a variety of tools and knowledge entries in various formats, on the topics of Fake news, Critical thinking, Digital diversity, Active citizenship. To begin with, you can check the introductory explanations below.

The repository is open & evolving – you can suggest topic-related resources at office@expertpool.bg

Fake news

It is important to distinguish between different phenomena that are commonly referred to as ‘disinformation’:

– misinformation is false or misleading content shared without harmful intent though the effects can still be harmful, e.g. when people share false information with friends and family in good faith;

– disinformation is false or misleading content that is spread with an intention to deceive or secure economic or political gain and which may cause public harm;

– information influence operation refers to coordinated efforts by either domestic or foreign actors to influence a target audience using a range of deceptive means, including suppressing independent information sources in combination with disinformation; and

– foreign interference in the information space, often carried out as part of a broader hybrid operation, can be understood as coercive and deceptive efforts to disrupt the free formation and expression of individuals’ political will by a foreign state actor or its agents74.

For each type of these phenomena, and depending on the actor, channel and impact, different policy responses are required, in accordance with fundamental rights and democratic standards. For example, misinformation, where there is no intention to deceive, cause public harm or make an economic gain, can be tackled essentially by proactive communication, providing reliable information and raising awareness of the need to critically assess content and sources. To address the other phenomena, where there is a harmful intent, a more robust response is needed and our capabilities need to be continuously developed. You can find resources supporting these efforts in the #FakeNews tag in the ODR.

Critical thinking

Many people think that critical thinking is related to criticizing. In a sense of the word to express disapproval of someone or something but it’s rather something else. Word ‘critical’ is related to a greek word κριτικός ‎(kritikós, “of or for judging, able to discern”). Critical thinking is a skill of thinking and reasoning in which thoughts are assessed for its clarity, accuracy, relevance and logicalness. It doesn’t include accepting all arguments and conclusions which may occur. During this process is important to ask for more informations, to question the source and one’s own beliefs and be open to alternative possibilities and evidence that doesn’t support preferred opinions.

Although collocation ‘critical thinking’ has its roots in the mid-late 20th century, the concept and its idea can be traced to Ancient Greece about 2,500 years ago. Big personality for critical thinking is Socrates. Many know his method of questioning sometimes called as “Socratic Questioning” and is still valued as a one of the best critical thinking teaching strategy. Also he promoted the importance of seeking evidence, examining reasoning and assumptions. Analyzing not just what is said but also who said it and how it correspond with reality.

So briefly critical thinking is self-guided rational thinking trying to reason at the highest level of quality. It involves checking one’s own thought and purificate it from egocentric tendencies. It is important try to avoid mistakes in reasoning, prejudices, biases, distortions and other fallacies caused by human irrationality. To further enhance and facilitate your interest in the topic, look up the resources under the #CriticalThinking tag in the ODR.

Digital diversity

Diversity starts with our uniqueness compared to other human beings. It continues with our age, sex, race, culture, religion, profession, and other aspects of our individual identity. Diversity is also about our local communities, regions, and nations. Respect for diversity, while building on our common values and desires, is key in building a prosperous, inclusive, and harmonious society.

As diversity nurtures innovation and creativity, it has helped spur many digital developments. From the early days, the internet has been an important enabler of diversity through the inclusion of a wide range of individuals and cultures. Lately, however, tech platforms have facilitated the creation of echo chambers among groups, entrenching like-minded individuals in spaces where they are not exposed to diversity in individuals, language, and communication style.

The future of digitalisation and our society depends on at least protecting diversity, and at best, nurturing it. In particular, it will be a challenge for emerging digital developments like AI platforms, which may sacrifice diversity as they aim to achieve economic optimisation. To enable and nurture diversity across the digital domain ,we have gathered several key resources in our ODR under the #DigitalDiversity tag.

Active citizenship

Democracy, the rule of law and fundamental rights are the foundations on which the European Union is based. Democracy is a core European value, and a precondition for EU membership. The EU’s citizens see democracy, human rights and the rule of law as its most important asset.

Democracy allows citizens to shape laws and public policies at European, national, regional and local levels. It requires safeguards, checks and balances, and institutions that fulfil their roles and uphold the rules of pluralistic democratic debate. For participation to be meaningful, citizens must also be able to form their own judgements – they should be able to make electoral choices in a public space where a plurality of views can be expressed freely and where free media, academia and civil society can play their role in stimulating open debate, free from malign interference, either domestic or foreign. Democracy can only thrive in a climate where freedom of information and freedom of expression are both upheld, in line with the Charter of Fundamental Rights, allowing everyone to express their views, regardless how critical they are towards the governments and those in power

Our European democratic cultures, in all their diversity, are being challenged by the digital transformation. Efforts to support a vibrant civil society and to promote and enhance democratic participation can be found in the #ActiveCitizenship tag in the ODR.

Factcheck.bg

The mission of Factcheck.bg is to counter the increasing pollution of Bulgaria’s media environment by disinformation and misinformation.

Critical Thinking Skills

The Skills You Need Guide to Life. Easy-to-read summary of the essential skills you need

Expert group report on Media Literacy

The mission of Factcheck.bg is to counter the increasing pollution of Bulgaria’s media environment by disinformation and misinformation.

EU citizenship

Rights of EU citizens, the citizens’ initiative, reports, citizen surveys and more information on EU citizenship.

Snopes

Snopes is the internet’s definitive fact-checking resource.

Playing 4 Soft Skills

Critical thinking in changing times

Measures to implementing the digital environment

UNESCO policy paper

Crash Course

A Crash Course on privacy online

PolitiFact

PolitiFact is a fact-checking website that rates the accuracy of claims by elected officials and others on its Truth-O-Meter.

CriThink

The main objective of this Erasmus+ project is the exchange good practices on the topic to learning of Critical Thinking of the adult population and especially seniors

Study on Media Plurality and Diversity Online

The Study on Media Plurality and Diversity Online investigates media pluralism and diversity online, prominence and discoverability of general interest content and services, and measures concerning market plurality and the concentration of economic resources.

Guidelines, Recommendations, Best Practices

General guidance (including guidelines, recommendations and best practice) to clarify the law and to promote common understanding of EU data protection laws

Hoaxy

Hoaxy is a tool that visualizes the spread of information online using the Twitter Search API.

PRACTICE

Preventing Radicalism through Critical Thinking Competences

Digital cultural diversity

A briefing of the EU Parliament

Dark patterns in social media platform interfaces: How to recognise and avoid them

The European Data Protection Board (EDPB) is an independent European body, which contributes to the consistent application of data protection rules throughout the European Union, and promotes cooperation between the EU’s data protection authorities. The EDPB is established by the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), and is based in Brussels.

False, Misleading, Clickbait-y, and/or Satirical “News” Sources

Tips for analyzing news sources

Media, Information & Critical Thinking Resource Pool

A resource pool dedicated to Media and Information Literacy

Digital diversity across Europe: Recommendations to ensure children across Europe equally benefit from digital technology

А policy brief

EU-Citizen.Science

EU-Citizen.Science is an online platform for sharing knowledge, tools, training and resources for citizen science – by the community, for the community.
The vision for the platform is to serve as a Knowledge Hub and to become the European reference point for citizen science in aid of its mainstreaming.

Fake News Detection Details

Fake Bananas – Fake News Detection with Stance Detection

PACT
POLITICAL ACTIVISM & CRITICAL THINKING

The aim of this project is to find out how people who may be at risk of radicalization can be methodically strengthened in order to participate in socially relevant topics, also on a political level.

An inclusive and social Europe that promotes participation and builds trust

DIGITALEUROPE is the leading trade association representing digitally transforming industries in Europe.

Cos4Cloud, a European Horizon 2020 project to boost citizen science technologies

Cos4Cloud is developing thirteen technological services to improve citizen observatories by helping them to increase the quantity and the quality of observations.

FactCheck.org

FactCheck.org. FactCheck.org is a nonprofit website that aims to reduce the level of deception and confusion in U.S. politics, by providing original research on misinformation and hoaxes.

Uncommon Sense Teaching Specialization

The Uncommon Sense Teaching Specialization is a foundational program that prepares you to teach based on leading-edge insights from neuroscience, cognitive psychology, and movie-making.

Cultural Diversity in the Digital Age: EU Competences, Policies and Regulations for Diverse Audiovisual and Online Content

A research paper

European citizenship : an institutional challenge

A research paper
Debunk EU
“Debunk EU” is an independent technological analytical centre and an NGO, whose main task is to research disinformation in the public space and execute educational media literacy campaigns.
The Neuroscience of Learning–and How It Can Inform Educational Policy

A video presentation

The Charter Implementation Toolkit (CIT)

The EU Platform of Diversity Charters to support companies, public institutions and non-profit organisations in placing diversity, inclusion and solidarity at the heart of their activities.

European citizenship : an institutional challenge

The study analysed the barriers and problems faced by EU citizens who reside in another EU country (‘mobile EU citizens’) when it comes to exercising their rights to vote and stand as candidates in the Member State of residence.
Botometer
Botometer (formerly BotOrNot) checks the activity of a Twitter account and gives it a score. Higher scores mean more bot-like activity.
The Molecule of More: How a Single Chemical in Your Brain Drives Love, Sex, and Creativity–and Will Determine the Fate of the Human Race, by Daniel Z. Lieberman and Michael E. Long.
A book on learning and thinking

Fostering digital representation of EU regional and minority languages: the Digital Language Diversity Project

A research paper

5 – Union Citizenship: Supra- and Post-National, Transnational or International?
A research paper
EUvsDisinfo
EUvsDisinfo is the flagship project of the European External Action Service’s East StratCom Task Force(opens in a new tab). It was established in 2015 to better forecast, address, and respond to the Russian Federation’s ongoing disinformation campaigns affecting the European Union, its Member States, and countries in the shared neighbourhood.

The Brain Doesn’t Think the Way You Think It Does

A post on how our brains work and how it affects our thinking
European Capitals of Inclusion and Diversity Award

The Award is open to all local authorities in the EU who are building fairer societies by promoting diversity and inclusion

Selected Online Reading on European Citizenship

A list of selected books, electronic books and articles from the European Parliament Library

Learning to Defend Yourself Against Disinformation: An Essential Skill in the 21st Century

EUvsDisinfo’s core objective is to increase public awareness and understanding of the Kremlin’s disinformation operations, and to help citizens in Europe and beyond develop resistance to digital information and media manipulation.

Learning How To Learn for Youth

An online MOOC on learning how to learn and thinking

Cultural Diversity in the Digital Age: EU Competences, Policies and Regulations for Diverse Audiovisual and Online Content

A research paper

EU citizenship report
2020
Find out what the EU institutions are doing to strengthen your EU citizenship rights across the Member States and abroad.

EU DisinfoLab

EU DisinfoLab is an independent non-profit organisation focused on tackling sophisticated disinformation campaigns targeting the EU, its member states, core institutions, and core values.

Critical thinking skills

Resources from EPALE

MYSTY

The MYSTY project provides a means for teachers to share and embed innovative teaching practice to enhance awareness of cultural diversity. At the same time it increases pupils’ cultural awareness and expression and enhance their social and civic competence.

Implementation of citizenship education in the EU
Research paper

Disinformation about migration in the EU

The European Policy Centre (EPC) is an independent, not-for-profit think tank dedicated to fostering European integration through analysis and debate, supporting and challenging decision-makers at all levels to make informed decisions based on evidence and analysis, and providing a platform for engaging partners, stakeholders and citizens in EU policy-making and in the debate about the future of Europe.

CRITICAL DEMOCRACY

Using Critical Thinking as an Educational Tool to Build a More Democratic, Inclusive and Sustainable Society

MYSTY

Disinformation on the coronavirus is thriving. It is important that you get updated information from authoritative sources only.
European Union citizenship and democracy
Eurobarometer report

How to Improve Critical Thinking Skills

EU Business School (EU) is an international, professionally accredited, high-ranking business school with campuses in Barcelona, Geneva and Munich, as well as our Digital Campus.

CRITHINKEDU

The ‘Critical Thinking Across the European Higher Education Curricula – CRITHINKEDU’ project arises from the background and experience of European Higher Education Institutions, business corporations and Non-Governmental Organisations, and their ongoing concern to improve the quality of learning in universities and across different sectors, which converge in a common need on how to better support the development of Critical Thinking (CT) according to labour market needs and social challenges.